By Duncan Mackay

Athens 2004 gold medallist Moon Dae-sung is set to face an IOC ethics investigation after losing an appeal against plagiarism allegations ©Getty ImagesAn International Olympic Committee (IOC) Ethics Commission investigation into claims South Korean member Moon Dae-sung plagiarised his doctoral thesis is set to be reopened after he lost a court case in Seoul today.


Earlier this year, Seoul's Kookmin University revoked the degree of Moon, winner of a taekwondo gold medal at Athens 2004, after ruling he had copied parts of a local scholar's doctoral thesis.

But he filed a suit against the school, demanding that it reversed the decision. 

The Seoul Northern District Court, however, backed the school's decision, ruling that parts of Moon's paper clearly matched another person's work.

Moon had received doctorate in August 2007 with a paper entitled the "Effect of Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation on Flexibility and Isokinetic Muscle Strength in Taekwondo Practitioners".

But In March 2012, it was alleged he had copied large portions of the work written by the other researcher.  

Moon Dae-sung was an influential member of the team involved in Pyeongchang's successful bid to host the 2018 Winter Olympics and Paralympics ©Getty ImagesMoon Dae-sung was an influential member of the team involved in Pyeongchang's successful bid to host the 2018 Winter Olympics and Paralympics ©Getty Images

Kookmin University conducted an investigation and ruled that Moon's paper "goes beyond what is normally permitted by the academic community" and that it was full of "serious plagiarisms".

They formally stripped Moon, who had played a leading role in Pyeongchang's successful bid for the 2018 Winter Olympics and Paralympics, of the degree in March. 

Moon, 36, appealed on the basis that he had permission to use the work of the fellow researcher and that the decision to strip him of his doctorate was politically motivated. 

As well as being a member of the IOC, Moon holds a Parliamentary seat in a district in the southern port city of Busan, representing South Korea's ruling Saenuri Party.

He had left the party amid the allegations but rejoined the party in February. 

An investigation into the allegations against Moon had been launched by the IOC Ethics Commission soon after the original allegation was made.

But, after repeated attempts to ask Kookmin University for its own findings proved unsuccessful, in December 2013 the case was closed pending further developments.

The IOC Ethics Commission investigation was re-opened following the decision to revoke Moon's degree, only for it to be suspended again when he launched legal action in South Korea.

Moon Dae-sung became a national hero in South Korea after winning the Olympic gold medal in the taekwondo over 80 kilogram category at Athens 2004 ©Getty ImagesMoon Dae-sung became a national hero in South Korea after winning the Olympic gold medal in the taekwondo over 80 kilogram category at Athens 2004 ©Getty Images

The case is similar to scandal involving another IOC member, Hungary's Pal Schmitt, in 2012.

On that occasion Schmitt, a double Olympic fencing gold medallist and IOC member since 1983, was reprimanded by the Ethics Commission after a panel at Semmelweis University found his thesis had been plagiarised and revoked his academic title.

The scandal also forced Schmitt to step down as President of Hungary.

But Schmitt was allowed to stay on as a member of the IOC following a reprimand and a self-imposed permanent suspension from joining any of its commissions.

Moon was elected as a member of the IOC Athletes' Commission for an eight-year term during the 2008 Olympics in Beijing.

His term is due to end in 2016.

A spokesman for the IOC told insidethegames that they would study the findings of the Seoul court before making any comment. 

Contact the writer of this story at [email protected]


Related stories
May 2014: IOC suspends ethics investigation into Moon Dae-sung "plagiarism"
March 2014: Moon Dae-sung facing IOC investigation after being "found guilty of plagiarism"
December 2013: Ethics Commission investigation against IOC member Moon closed
May 2012: IOC member caught in plagiarism scandal offers to resign from university
April 2012: South Korean IOC member implicated in plagiarism scandal leaving new political career in balance